Richard Beasley was a conman and serial killer who posed as a preacher and in 2011, posted advertisements on Craigslist to entice men to work with him on his farm. Once on the property, Beasley hunted them down like wild animals, then killed and buried them. In this episode, his daughter Tonya, who lives with the guilt of teaching her father how to post ads on Craigslist, meets Nick Kern, whose father, Timothy was one of Beasley’s four victims.