You know and love Shay Mitchell from ‘Pretty Little Liars,’ ‘You,’ and your beauty inspiration board on Pinterest—but now, we’re challenging the actress to give her very own makeup artist a fullbeat. Catch Shay attempting a stunning, emerald green smokey eyes on Ash Holm, aka the queen of sexy, natural makeup. Shay started out pretty strong, but once she got to the eyeliner portion...well, things took a turn! In the end, both Shay and Ash learned some valuable lessons, like why today’s makeup trends are way better than those of the past, and that makeup wipes are a blessing. Check out Shay's cute BÉIS cosmetics case here: https://beistravel.com/products/the-cosmetic-case-in-metallic-pink