The MAN57 mens garnet ring is a perfect example of what you should look for when choosing a garnet mens ring. It does not matter whether you choose a gold or sterling silver mens garnet ring. Both rings should have good metal weight and craftsmanship. These features along with the design would define how durable and sturdy your mens garnet ring would be in the longtern. See a collection of garnet rings here: http://www.gemstonejewelry.kaijewels.com/garnet-ring-all-kj-10.htm