Addison Rae’s surprise appearance as Evelyn Hartley — a real-life teen once linked to Ed Gein’s string of suspected victims — has sparked major buzz following the release of the Monsters: The Ed Gein Story trailer on Netflix.

The unexpected casting marks Rae’s most dramatic role to date, shifting from TikTok stardom to the gritty world of true crime.

While some fans are praising her bold career move, others are questioning whether her celebrity persona fits the tone of this chilling Netflix series.