Annie Oakley - "The Saga of Clement O'Toole" (1956)

A young man is mistaken for a notorious outlaw and has a hard time convincing Diablo's townspeople that he didn't commit a stagecoach robbery.

Though Annie Oakley and Susan Meriwhether believe him, their confidence is shaken when he is present went the town's bank is robbed by outlaws who appear to recognize him.

Director: Ray Nazarro
Writers: Robert Schaefer (teleplay), Eric Freiwald (teleplay)
Stars: Gail Davis, Jimmy Hawkins, Brad Johnson

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0513489/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1